Florida Attorney General Reports February 16, 1979 (Ago)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-02-1979
Roger G. Saberson City Attorney Delray Beach QUESTION: Can a city spend public funds to maintain privately owned streets in a residential subdivision located within the city without violating s. 10, Art. VII of the State Constitution? SUMMARY: A municipality may not lawfully expend public funds to repair or maintain privately owned roads or streets located within the municipality. Any expenditure of public funds must be for a primarily public purpose, with only incidental or secondary benefit to private interests. I must point out, first, that only the courts, not this office, can officially determine and rule whether a particular expenditure of funds by a municipality violates s. 10, Art. VII, or any other provision of the State Constitution. Short of judicial adjudication of this matter, it is primarily and initially your responsibility as city attorney to advise the city council as to the validity of a particular expenditure or the likelihood that it might be ruled unconstitutional by the courts. You stated in your letter that the roads or streets in question are `private streets' and that they are `privately owned.' Given this premise, it is certainly to be presumed that maintenance or repair of such private streets would be the responsibility of the private owners thereof. The test for any expenditure of public funds by a municipality or other governmental entity in this state is whether the expenditure is for a purpose which primarily benefits the public, with any benefits to private interests being only incidental and secondary. O'Neill v. Burns, 198 So.2d 1 (Fla. 1967). I assume that in making the various references to `private streets' and `privately owned streets' in your letters you have determined that no municipal or public right to use of or easement over such roads or streets exists or has arisen, such as by prescriptive easement, common law dedication, or operation of law.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit