Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit January 19, 1979, 77-2065, 77-2066 and 77-2064 (United States v. Roger Clabaugh, United States of America v. Hugh Colomb, United States of America v. Earl McGeorge)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-01-1979
PER CURIAM:
I. FACTS
The three appellants were convicted of two separate bank robberies by a jury. 18 U.S.C. § 2113(a)(d). Appellant Clabaugh was also subsequently convicted of a third count of bank robbery in a court trial based on stipulated facts. Clabaugh was sentenced to concurrent 25-year terms on each count. Appellant Colomb received concurrent 25-year sentences, and appellant McGeorge received concurrent 20-year sentences on the same two counts. Timely notices of appeal followed.
The most substantial question on appeal is whether the detention which led to appellants’ arrest and the seizure of critical evidence was lawful. The jury instructions on reasonable doubt, the limitations on voir dire questioning, and the admission of certain other evidence are also challenged.
II. DETENTION
Appellants and a fourth man were “stopped” in their car by two Los Angeles narcotics officers on January 12, 1977. By the time the officers reached appellants’ automobile, they had sighted, in plain view, a pistol on the car seat which gave the officers probable cause to arrest. Other inculpatory evidence was found in plain view and in a search incident to arrest.
The day before the stop and arrest, the same two officers spotted the foursome in the same vehicle in a parking lot near San Fernando Road. The time was 4:00 p. m. One of the policemen, Officer Birney, recognized the fourth man, Coughlin, whom he had previously arrested twice and knew as a narcotics user and convicted burglar. The officers followed the car as it slowly traveled down San Fernando Road. Although the officers were in plain clothes and driving an unmarked car, Coughlin and appellant McGeorge waved to them. The surveillance lasted only briefly that day.
At 3:30 p. m. the next day, the officers saw the vehicle traveling south on San Fernando Road. Again, they followed the car, this time without being recognized. Appellants’ vehicle traveled slowly (20 — 25 m. p. h.) and slowed further at each motel passed.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit