Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit January 23, 1979, 325, Docket 78-7412 (British American & Eastern Co., Inc. And Frederick L. Sunley, Plaintiffs v. Wirth Limited, Wirth Incorporated and Manfred F. Wirth)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-01-1979

LUMBARD, Circuit Judge:

In this diversity case, defendants Wirth Limited, Wirth Incorporated, and Manfred F. Wirth (“Wirth”) appeal from a judgment entered by Judge Knapp in the Southern District on July 10,1978, after a bench trial, insofar as it dismissed Wirth’s defenses and counterclaims and awarded damages for breach of contract totalling $27,085.84 to plaintiffs British American and Eastern Co., Inc. and Frederick L. Sunley (“Sunley”).

1

On appeal, Wirth asserts that Sunley should not recover (1) because Sunley failed to prove performance of the contract, (2) because Sunley’s acceptance of alleged “bribes” breached the contract, and (3) because Sunley’s allegedly defamatory statements with respect to Wirth’s business performance breached the contract. Wirth also contends that he is entitled to recover all sums paid to Sunley pursuant to the contract, the amount of the alleged “bribes” paid to Sunley, and damages for libel. With respect to Wirth’s defense and counterclaim growing out of Sunley’s allegedly defamatory statements, we affirm. With respect to Wirth’s claims that Sunley failed to prove performance and that Sunley’s acceptance of bribes breached the contract and entitled Wirth to recover the monies paid as bribes, we remand for further findings of fact and conclusions of law.

Plaintiff Sunley was for twenty years the United States representative for an Austrian steel mill known as VMW. In 1973, when Sunley reached 74 years of age, VMW began looking for a younger successor to Sunley. Relying in part on Sunley’s recommendation, VMW engaged defendant Wirth to be its United States representative in February, 1974.

*78

On February 22, 1974, as part of the transitional arrangement, Sunley and Wirth entered into a written agreement which provided in relevant part that:

FLS [Sunley] and MFW [Wirth] agree .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.