Court of Appeals for the First Circuit July 17, 1979, 78-2067 (Forrest Stanley Judd and Iva Jean Judd v. First Federal Savings and Loan Association of Indianapolis)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-07-1979
PER CURIAM.
Forrest and Iva Judd, appellants, filed an action against Meridian Mortgage Company (Meridian) and five Indianapolis banks for conspiracy to require mortgagors to deposit advance tax and insurance payments in escrow accounts on which the mortgagors receive no interest, all in violation of antitrust laws.
Appellants sought class action certification, the class to consist of all persons who obtained mortgage loans from the defendant mortgage company and banks.
In October 1976, the district court certified the class as all persons who obtained mortgage loans from Meridian between January 1, 1960 and July 22, 1976. Appellants moved to enlarge the certified class. The district court denied the motion.
In July 1977, the district court ordered appellants’ counsel to compile a list of the names and addresses of class members by making a search of Meridian’s business records (1977 order).
In November 1977, appellants learned that Meridian had a computer generated list of all of Meridian’s 11,000 mortgagors, which list included between 1,650 and 4,000 names of mortgagors who are not within the certified class because they obtained their mortgages either before or after the specified period or from other companies.
Appellants filed a motion for permission to use the computer list for class notification purposes because it would cost between $16,000 and $24,000 less to use the computer list than to compile a class list from Meridian’s files. Appellants agreed to include in the notice an explanation to help mortgagors determine whether they belong to the plaintiff class.
Meridian objected to the motion on the grounds that the computer list would confuse a great number of its customers, would require it to spend much time and money to answer inquiries generated by the notices and would damage Meridian’s good will.
In July 1978, the district court denied appellants’ motion and ordered them to comply with the 1977 order.
*822
Appellants appeal from the July 1978 order.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit