Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit October 5, 1979, 76-4261 (Ralph Carpenter v. Klosters Rederi A/s, a Foreign Corporation, D/B/A Norwegian Caribbean Lines)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-10-1979

JONES, Circuit Judge:

The appellant, Klosters Rederi A/S, is a corporation of Norway doing business under the name of Norwegian Caribbean Lines. It operated cruise ships from Florida ports. The appellee, Ralph C. Carpenter is a citizen and resident of Broward County, Florida. Carpenter purchased a “Passage Con

*12

tract Ticket” from the appellee shipowner for a cruise on the M/S Sunward sailing from and returning to Miami, Florida. The top line of the ticket read, “Norwegian Caribbean Lines Passage Contract Ticket.” Immediately below, and in bold type was the provision, “Issued subject to the terms and conditions printed on the cover of this contract ticket which form part thereof.” Among the terms and conditions referred to and in the fine print on the cover of the ticket was the provision that: “The acceptance of this ticket by a passenger shall be deemed to be an undertaking and acknowledgment that he accepts on behalf of himself and all other persons traveling under this ticket and his and their heirs and representatives that he and they accept and agree to all the conditions of carriage herein set out or otherwise notified to the passenger by the owners.” The terms and conditions contain a one-year suit time limitation: “Suit to recover any claim shall not be maintainable . . . unless commenced within one year after the date of the accident or loss.”

On September 14, 1973 Carpenter brought an action against the shipowner seeking damages for personal injuries. Federal jurisdiction of diversity of citizenship was asserted. In the complaint it was alleged that Carpenter, on October 15,1972, while a passenger on the shipowner’s vessel, the M/S Sunward, and while the vessel was on the high seas, stepped from an elevator onto a wet and slippery deck, fell and was injured. The shipowner denied negligence and asserted that the deck was dry. At the trial of the cause a verdict was returned for the shipowner and judgment was entered on the verdict.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.