Missouri Court of Appeals December 3, 1979, No. KCD 30560 (Clark v. City of Trenton)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-12-1979

SOMERVILLE, Presiding Judge.

The genesis of this litigation was an ordinance passed by the governing body of the City of Trenton, Missouri, to impose a city sales tax and a requisite election authorizing its imposition. See generally Sections 94.500 to 94.570, RSMo 1978.

On July 13,1978, as a sequel to the above events, a petition captioned “Petition For Declaratory Judgment”, naming the City of Trenton, Missouri, as defendant (hereinafter city), was filed by Jack Clark and others (hereinafter contestants) in the Circuit Court of Grundy County, Missouri. On July 27, 1978, the contestants, by leave of court, filed what was captioned “First Amended Petition For Declaratory Judgment”, to which the city filed a “Motion to Dismiss First Amended Petition” which was sustained by the trial court.

By way of a timely appeal the contestants seek reversal of the judgment of dismissal on the ground that the trial court incorrectly construed the “First Amended Petition For Declaratory Judgment” as being one to “contest” the election held by the city on April 4,1978, to authorize imposition of the city sales tax.

In order to set the stage for appellate review, it is important to take stock of what the trial court had before it to support its judgment of dismissal. As no supporting affidavits were filed, and no evidentiary *258hearing was held, the trial court had before it only the contestants initial and amended petitions, the city’s motion to dismiss and written suggestions of the city supporting its motion to dismiss and written suggestions of the contestants opposing the motion to dismiss. Although the matters raised by the city in its motion to dismiss did not prove themselves, they could be supported by appropriate allegations, if there were such, which might be contained in contest-, ants’ petition and by evidence found in the transcript. Light v. Lang, 539 S.W.2d 795, 797 (Mo.App.1976).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.