Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York July 12, 1979 (Claim of O'Shea v. City of Binghamton)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-07-1979

Appeal from a decision of the Workers’ Compensation Board, filed April 26, 1978. A referee held that the claimant had sustained a compensable aggravation/activation of pre-existing tuberculosis due to smoke inhalation on October 7, 1974, and awarded benefits for the period of November 5, 1974 to December 30, 1975 at temporary total disability and from December 30, 1975 to January 13, 1977 at one-third partial disability. The employer and its insurance carrier appealed that decision to the board upon the ground that as to the period of November 5, 1974 to December 30, 1975 the claimant had not shown any disability causally related to the tuberculosis and that as of June 3, 1976 the tuberculosis was no longer disabling. The board’s decision recites: "After review, the Board finds on the medical evidence that the claimant herein had a temporary aggravation of his tubercular condition due to smoke inhalation on October 7, 1974 and that claimant’s disability from November 5, 1974 to December 30, 1975 was due to the pre-existing tuberculosis. The disability from December 30, 1975 to June 3, 1976 was mild and partial. Thereafter, claimant had no evidence of further causally related disability attributable to accidental injury of October 7, 1974. We so find.” Based upon these findings, the board rescinded the award from November 5 to December 30, 1975 and limited the award for partial disability to the period ending June 3, 1976. The claimant appeals upon the grounds that the rescission of benefits for the period of November 5, 1974 to December 30, 1975 is in contradiction of the board’s own findings and, further, that the medical evidence relied upon by the board shows a continuing disability after June 3, 1976. The claimant’s contention that the board misinterpreted or "misread” the report and testimony of the carrier’s medical consultant is not persuasive. That expert found that there was no further measurable disability for active tuberculosis as of June 3, 1976.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.