New York Supreme Court March 30, 1979 (People v. Edelstein)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-03-1979

*1019OPINION OF THE COURT

Harold J. Rothwax, J.

The defendants move to suppress evidence obtained as the result of court-ordered electronic surveillance on the grounds that the officers who executed the warrant failed to adequately minimize the interception of communications not otherwise subject to eavesdropping. (CPL 700.30, subd 7.)

The threshold question is whether the movants have standing to invoke the statutory remedies.

In this State, the law on standing, in relation to the fruits of electronic surveillance, is asertained through a statutory cross reference between CPL 710.10 (subd 5) and CPLR 4506 (subd 2), which defines an "aggrieved person” to include the sender or receiver in a telephone conversation or a participant in an oral conversation which was overheard without a party’s consent. The statute also includes as an "aggrieved person” those against whom the overhearing was directed (CPLR 4506, subd 2, par [c]). Though the defendants fall within these statutory parameters, and are thus able to assert claims regarding invasions of their own privacy rights sufficient to warrant an analysis of their own conversations, they request that the court allow them to challenge allegedly improper police conduct (the failure to minimize) which allegedly invaded the privacy of others. The statutes are silent as to the standing of the defendants in this situation.

Indeed, the legislative history of section 2510 et seq. of title 18 of the United States Code, the model upon which the New York statutes are drawn (see People v McGrath, 46 NY2d 12, 26), indicates an intent to reject a concept of standing which would permit a third party to vicariously assert the violation of another’s rights.

The late Senator Philip Hart sponsored an amendment to section 2510 of title 18 of the United States Code which would have given standing to "person[s] against whom the communication, or evidence derived therefrom, is sought to be used,” to challenge illegal police surveillance.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.