New York Supreme Court January 25, 1979 (New York Teachers Pension Ass'n v. Teachers' Retirement System)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-01-1979

OPINION OF THE COURT

Shanley N. Egeth, J.

In this article 78 proceeding, petitioners seek to compel respondent retirement system to make available for copying a list of its present beneficiaries. One petitioner is a not-for-profit corporation whose principal purpose is to investigate legislation and other governmental action and decisions affecting the pension funds administered by respondent and to inform its membership and other retirees as to the results of such investigation. The other petitioner is the president of the corporation.

Respondent has refused the demand of petitioners for the desired information on the basis of an opinion of its legal advisor, the Corporation Counsel. The opinion states that respondent’s refusal to provide such information may properly be based on the fact that its disclosure would result in an *1119unwarranted invasion of personal privacy (Public Officers Law, § 89, subd 2, par [b]) as information which "would be used for commercial or fund-raising purposes” (Public Officers Law, §89, subd 2, par [b], cl [iii]) and as information "of a personal nature when disclosure would result in economic or personal hardship to the subject party and * * * not relevant to the work of the agency requesting or maintaining it” (Public Officers Law, § 89, subd 2, par [b], cl [iv]).

The petition is granted. Respondent has the burden of establishing that the demanded information is not of a sort which it is required to make available (Public Officers Law, § 89, subd 4, par [b]). Respondent has failed, by a substantial measure, to satisfy its burden. No factual substantiation has been submitted in support of its contention that the information would be used for commercial or fund raising purposes. As a not-for-profit corporation, petitioner may not engage in commercial activities.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.