New York Supreme Court September 14, 1979 (Fiacco v. Carey)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-09-1979

*908OPINION OF THE COURT

Leonard A. Weiss, J.

Petitioner, Paul Fiacco, seeks a preliminary injunction restraining and enjoining respondents pursuant to CPLR 6301 pending a determination of the underlying action for a permanent injunction, from conducting a preliminary hearing or from taking any other steps or measures to make a determination concerning petitioner’s alleged parole violations which arise out of an incident on July 15, 1979 — which incident has also resulted in criminal charges including felony accusations being made against petitioner. Petitioner requests that this court issue an order directing respondents to conduct any proceedings on the parole violation charges after completion of petitioner’s criminal trial so that petitioner will not be forced during the parole revocation proceedings to testify against himself or divulge the names of the witnesses or trial tactics which petitioner will use at the trial on the criminal charges.

Respondents oppose the motion for preliminary injunction on the grounds (1) that the preliminary hearing sought to be enjoined by petitioner was already held on August 2, 1979 and that petitioner’s application should not be construed so as to encompass that injunction against a final parole revocation hearing, and (2) that as a matter of law petitioner has not demonstrated an adequate basis for a preliminary injunction because petitioner’s present request is based on the possibility that he may be required to reveal evidence which would violate his privilege against self incrimination, his right to effective assistance of counsel, and his Fourteenth Amendment rights, if the State was allowed to proceed in accordance with the Executive Law and conduct the parole revocation hearing prior to the criminal trial arising from the same incident, without showing a reasonable probability that petitioner would be required to divulge said evidence at the parole revocation hearing.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.