New York Supreme Court June 11, 1979 (Coalition Against Rent Increase Passalongs v. Rent Guidelines Board)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-06-1979
OPINION OF THE COURT
Martin B. Stecher, J.
This is an application by the plaintiffs, rent stabilized *103tenants and various associations of tenants, for an order enjoining, pendente lite, the issuance and enforcement of "any surcharge order or other addition to any rent guidelines order, and collecting any surcharge or other increase pursuant to Rent Guidelines Order Nos. 10A and 10B;” and to enjoin the defendants from "issuing and enforcing Rent Guidelines Order Nos. 10A and 10B and collecting any rental pursuant to said orders retroactively or prospectively.”
A cross motion is made by defendants New York City Conciliation and Appeals Board and its chairman to dismiss the complaint as to them.
Pursuant to my decision dated September 25, 1978, and the order issued thereon dated October 31, 1978, the Rent Guidelines Board of the City of New York (Board) was, by reason of its failure to abide by the open meetings law (Public Officers Law, art 7) and for other procedural reasons, directed to consider its Rent Guidelines Order No. 10 de nova. The challenged orders are Rent Guidelines Order No. 10A which is the order promulgated on April 4, 1979 in lieu of Rent Guidelines Order No. 10; and Rent Guidelines Order No. 10B which is in the nature of a fuel surcharge and which was adopted by the Board as a separate resolution on April 10, 1979, retroactive to March 1, 1979. The attack is made upon the following grounds:
(1) That the meetings at which the guidelines were adopted were procedurally defective in that they did not adhere to the terms of my order of October 31, 1978;
(2) That tenants were given insufficient opportunity to present data relating to Rent Guidelines Order No. 10B, the fuel surcharge;
(3) That the Board itself had insufficient opportunity to familiarize itself with and consider all of the data provided to the Board;
(4) That the provision in Order No.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit