Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania February 21, 1979, Appeal, No. 2685 C.D. 1978 (Aitkenhead v. Borough of West View)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-02-1979

Memorandum Opinion by

President Judge Bowman,

This is an appeal from an order of Judge John P. Flaherty, Jr. of the Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County dated November 16, 1978 preliminarily •enjoining the fluoridation of water treated at the West View Water Authority’s Neville Island facility. The preliminary decree states in part “. . . Said prohibition shall remain in effect until this Court holds a final hearing upon this matter, or the matter is submitted to, considered by and dealt with by the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Resources, taking into account the evidence submitted to this Court.” By order of this Court dated November 29, 1978, the preliminary injunction was superseded pending disposition of the appeal.

Appellees have filed a motion to dismiss the appeal for mootness on the ground that on or about January 10, 1979, the Department of Environmental Resources denied appellants permission to discontinue fluoridation and ordered that fluoridation continue. Appellees, in their motion, “concede and specifically stipulate that the condition of the aforementioned de*549cree dated November 16, 1978 requiring review by tbe Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Resources has been satisfied and tbe fluoridation prohibition ordered by Judge Flaherty is now of no effect i.e., appellants are free to continue fluoridation of tbe municipal water supply. ’ ’

Appellants have filed an answer to tbe motion to dismiss which represents that “appellants join with appellees in stipulating that tbe conditional preliminary decree bas been satisfied by tbe review and ruling of DER and is of no further effect.”

While we question appellees’ characterization of tbe order as “requiring” review by DER, we agree with tbe parties that tbe preliminary injunction bas been dissolved by virtue of DER’s action. By its own terms, tbe preliminary decree was to remain in effect until tbe occurrence of one of two conditions subsequent.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.