Ohio Supreme Court April 18, 1979, No. 78-593 (Loveland Education Ass'n v. Loveland City School District Board of Education)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-04-1979
Celebrezze, C. J.
The narrow issue raised in this appeal is whether the second amended complaint fails to state a cause of action pursuant to Civ. R. 12(B)(6). Our scrutiny is thus limited to the four corners of the complaint and the agreement incorporated as an exhibit thereto. As indicated above, the second amended complaint sought a declaratory judgment establishing the recognition agreement as a valid and legally enforceable'contract, voluntarily executed by both the board and the teachers association.
Appellants contend that judicial enforcement of the agreement would involve a court of law in the strictly legislative process of rule-making which is vested exclusively in a board of education. Furthermore, they assert that acknowledging the validity of these preliminary agreements would place a judicial stamp of approval on an unlawful delegation and impairment of the board’s statutory responsibility to manage and control its schools.2
*33We disagree. The underlying issne presented by this appeal does not involve judicial intervention into the rule-making prerogatives of the board. On the contrary, the relevant inquiry must be directed at the scope of the statutory authority of that administrative body to negotiate towards the ultimate goal of a collective bargaining agreement.
In reaching its decision that appellee’s complaint overcame the hurdle of a motion to dismiss, the Court of Appeals relied upon the rationale expressed in Dayton Teachers Assn. v. Dayton Bd. of Edn. (1975), 41 Ohio St. 2d 127. In that case we examined various provisions of R. C. Chapters 3313 and 3319 to ascertain whether a school board’s attempt to bind itself to a written collective bargaining agreement exceeded any statutory limitations placed upon its contractual power.
As a result of that analysis, we concluded, at page 131, that “a board of education has been granted broad discretionary powers in its dual role of manager of schools and employer of teachers.” (Emphasis added.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit