Ohio Supreme Court December 19, 1979, No. 79-379 (Transport Supply, Inc. v. Public Utilities Commission)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-12-1979

Jackson, J.

Appellant contends that the findings of fact of the commission are not supported by the record and that its opinion fails to state the reasons upon which the commission’s conclusions are based, as required by R. C. 4903.09.

The provisions of R. C. 4921.10 require every motor transportation company to obtain from the commission a certificate before commencing a proposed operation declaring that the “public convenience and necessity require such operation.” The burden of proof is on the applicant to demonstrate, inter alia, the public convenience and necessity for the proposed service and the inadequacy of existing transportation facilities or service. Alspaugh v. Pub. Util. Comm. (1946), 146 Ohio St. 267, 268. The issuance of a certificate is prohibited if it appears from the evidence that the existing service is “reasonably adequate.” R. C. 4921.10. See McLain v. Pub. Util. Comm. (1924), 110 Ohio St. 1 (interpreting the predecessor to R. C. 4921.10).

The record in the case at bar is voluminous. The facts, however, may be distilled into the following summary. During the winter of 1976-77, one of the most severe in recent memory, the curtailment in the distribution of natural gas caused a significant but temporary increase in demand for propane gas by companies who use it as an emergency standby fuel. Due to the extreme weather conditions and the shortage of available propane at pipeline terminals, long lines and loading delays occurred at the Lake Underground Storage Corporation facility.* This resulted in delays in the delivery of propane.

*157There was testimony by propane consumers that, under the circumstances, they did not view the delivery delays as the fault of the common carriers. There was, however, conflicting testimony by propane consumers over whether additional service from the Lake Underground storage facility would have been helpful in alleviating the emergency condition.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.