Louisiana Court of Appeal February 6, 1979, No. 9813 (Impola v. Martin)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-02-1979
BOUTALL, Judge.
This is a suit claiming damages arising from an incident between the plaintiff and certain security guards of Schwegmann Brothers Giant Supermarkets, Inc. The plaintiff, Helen Impola, based her action on assault and battery, unlawful arrest, defamation of character and false imprisonment. After a trial on the merits, the trial judge found in favor of defendant and plaintiff brings this appeal.
The testimony of appellant reconstructs the incident as follows: After paying for her groceries, she left the store and was accosted by a “tall white-headed man” in the parking lot. The man grabbed her by the shoulder and told her that he wanted her to go back into the store. The man then called a “blonde-headed lady” who told her that she was a New Orleans Police Officer. Appellant therefore consented to go back into the store.
Once inside the store, appellant claims that one security guard held her while the other pulled the basket away causing her to fall on her spine. The security guards then took her into an office where she was searched by one of the guards who put his hands in her blouse and pants causing her to fall from a bench and further injure herself.
The testimony of the security guards painted an entirely different picture of the incident. They state that appellant was *1322observed in the store with a jar of vitamins next to her purse and separate from the rest of her groceries. When she checked out the vitamins were not among the items paid for. Appellant was then questioned briefly outside the store by Pat Caligione, the blonde-haired lady and followed the security guard back into the store of her own accord.
Once back inside, appellant began yelling for a lawyer and a policeman and tried to pull the basket down on herself. Two or three of the security guards had their hands on the basket to prevent it from falling and hurting the woman. She was then helped into a security office and the police were notified.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit