Louisiana Court of Appeal June 5, 1979, No. 10159 (Riemer v. Marriott Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-06-1979

GULOTTA, Judge.

Plaintiffs appeal from the dismissal of their damage suit for injuries sustained by Mrs. Helen Riemer when she was struck on the head by a closing, descending door of a freight elevator in the Marriott Hotel.1

On the morning of April 10, 1975, Mrs. Riemer, along with several other ladies, was bringing flower table decorations to the hotel to be used in connection with a noonday luncheon to take place on the same day. According to plaintiff, as she arrived by automobile in the front driveway area of the hotel, she was directed to use the freight elevator located in the rear of the building. Her testimony was disputed by a hotel security officer who stated that because of the impatience of Mrs. Riemer and the other ladies, they insisted on using the elevator despite his instructions to them not to do so. According to this employee, the ladies had been told that they would have to wait for “a caterer’s manager” to use the elevator.

This elevator was described as having an inside mesh steel door which closed from top to bottom and two outer steel synchronized doors (one closing from the top and one closing from the bottom) which close at the middle. Approximately 10 or 12 seconds before the inner mesh door begins *739to close, a bell rings and continues to ring during the descent of this door. The outer doors do not commence to close until the inner door has reached the elevator floor. After the doors have opened they remain in that position for approximately 60 seconds and thereafter automatically close unless held open by an “open” button.

As Mrs. Riemer was approaching the elevator with the decorations in each hand, the closing inner mesh door struck her head causing her to “trip” resulting in her fall outside the elevator.

The trial judge, in written reasons, stated:

“REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

It is the opinion of the Court that the Plaintiffs did not meet the burden of proof imposed on them by law.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.