Supreme Court of Florida November 29, 1979, No. 57143 (Florida Bar)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-11-1979

ALDERMAN, Justice.

Sherman N. Smith, Jr., a member of The Florida Bar, seeks review of the denial of his petition for renewal of designation and raises two questions: Did the Board of Governors of The Florida Bar have the authority to delegate to the Designation Plan Appeal Committee its responsibility to hear appeals and to make final decisions under the Florida Designation Plan, and should the decision of the Designation Coordinating Committee, refusing to waive the thirty-hour continuing legal education requirement for renewal of designation, be reversed. We hold that the Board may not delegate its responsibility to make the final decision in designation disputes. Consequently, we find that it is not necessary for us to resolve the second question.

In 1976, Smith designated Corporate and Business Law, Real Property Law, and Wills, Estates and Estate Planning. In September, 1978, he sought to renew his designation and requested the Bar to waive the continuing legal education requirements. To show good cause for such waiver, Smith alleged that his practice is primarily devoted to his designated areas; that for more than thirty years he has had a Martindale-Hubbell A rating; that for five years he served as a district court of appeal judge; that he has served as a member of the Florida constitutional revision commission and the Supreme Court Standard Jury Instruction Committee and a member of numerous other committees and sections of the Bar; that he customarily scans each issue of The Florida Bar News, The Bar Journal, and every continuing legal education publication published by The Florida Bar and he reads every article that deals with the field of law in which he practices; that he reads every summary of the decisions of the appellate courts and the Supreme Court of Florida which are in his fields of practice; and that he reads the summaries of the legislative acts and actually reads the acts that are in his fields of practice.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.