Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit December 12, 1979, Nos. 78-1812, 78-2154 and 79-1045 (International Detective Service, Inc. v. Interstate Commerce Commission)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-12-1979

Opinion for the Court filed by Judge DAVIS.

DAVIS, Judge:

These three related motor carrier cases involve Interstate Commerce Commission decisions which reflect a new stress on the shipper’s need for competition. In each case the ICC granted applications for contract carrier permits providing for new entry into routes served by the armored carrier industry. Not surprisingly the existing carriers in those fields have challenged the Commission. We conclude that the agency adequately considered the statutory provisions in approving these new motor contract carrier permits, and that the final policy choice in favor of increased competition was within administrative discretion.

The armored service segment of the motor carrier industry includes a limited number of firms1 which provide the specialized handling, insurance requirements, and storage facilities for transporting high value commodities, including securities and money. A significant demand for such interstate transportation comes from the various Federal Reserve banks, which have traditionally undertaken to provide both member and nonmember banks in their regions with coin and currency.2 The two Reserve *337Banks involved in these three cases, Boston and San Francisco, rely primarily on armored carriers to ship the currency, arranging for service on the basis of long-term contracts.3 Both banks have desired and sought competitive bidding on their hauling contracts, b.ut both have required that a bidder have prior certification by the ICC.4 In Nos. 78-1812 and 79-1045, concerning the. Boston Federal Reserve Bank, before the grant of the permits challenged here there was only one authorized carrier (Brink’s) for most of the northeastern routes, with a second carrier (International Detective) authorized to make interstate deliveries in Connecticut and Rhode Island. In No.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.