Court of Appeals of Wisconsin October 26, 1979, No. 79-485 (State v. Nelson)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-10-1979

DONLIN, P.J.

Kevin R. Nelson was found guilty of snagging fish in violation of Wis. Adm. Code, sec. NR 20.07(1) (d).1 The violation occurred on May 17, 1978, while Nelson was fishing from a retaining wall of the Trempealeau Lock and Dam on the Minnesota side of the Mississippi River. Nelson was observed fishing from the retaining wall by a Department of Natural Resources warden who was in a shelter on the Wisconsin side of the river. Nelson appeals his conviction, contending that Wisconsin had no jurisdiction over him when he was fishing. He further argues that if Wisconsin did have jurisdiction, the Trempealeau County court was not the proper court to hear this matter.

Where Nelson was fishing, the Mississippi River forms the boundary between Wisconsin and Minnesota. Fed*857eral legislation granted Wisconsin and Minnesota concurrent jurisdiction over the waters of the Mississippi River that form their boundary.2 Nelson contends that his act of snagging fish occurred outside the territorial limits of the State of Wisconsin. He claims that the jurisdiction of the state can only extend to the center of the main channel of the Mississippi River.3 He acknowledges that Wisconsin and Minnesota have concurrent jurisdiction over the river. He argues, however, that Wisconsin is prohibited from enforcing its fishing regulations on the Minnesota side of the main channel.

As principal support for his argument, Nelson cites a Wisconsin case.4 His reliance is misplaced; the language of that case does not apply to this fact situation. The issue before the supreme court was whether a Minnesota warden could destroy a net that a Wisconsin fisherman had anchored to the bottom of the Mississippi River. The net was anchored on the Wisconsin side of the main channel. The laws of the State of Minnesota prohibited catching fish in this manner. It is clear from the opinion that Wisconsin permitted catching fish in this manner.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.