Court of Customs and Patent Appeals February 1, 1979, Appeal No. 78-595 (Randolph v. Shoberg)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-02-1979

lead-opinion

BALDWIN, Judge.

This is an appeal from the decision of the Board of Patent Interferences (board) awarding priority to Shoberg et al. (Shoberg), the senior party. We reverse.

Background

Shoberg was issued U.S. patent No. 3,938,603 entitled “Constant Moment Weigh Scale With Floating Flexure Beam” on February 17, 1976, on an application filed December 30, 1974. Randolph, the junior party, filed an application entitled “Multipoint Load-Summing Apparatus” on May 5, 1975. On February 10, 1977, Randolph amended his application by copying claims 1, 8 and 17 of the Shoberg patent and submitted his declaration and the declaration of his patent attorney, Dickinson, under 37 CFR 1.204(c) for the purpose of provoking an interference with the Shoberg patent.

Randolph’s declaration set forth the structure and mode of operation of an electromechanical load sensor but was silent about any testing of the device. Dickinson’s declaration merely related to the disclosure papers he had received from Randolph.

After considering these declarations, the Examiner of Interferences, by letter of August 11, 1977, issued to Randolph an order to show cause why summary judgment should not be entered against him under 37 CFR 1.228 for failing to make a sufficient showing under 37 CFR 1.204(c) to entitle him to a prima facie award of priority with respect to Shoberg’s filing date. The examiner stated Randolph’s declaration failed to set forth facts from which it could be concluded that he completely reduced his invention to practice prior to Shoberg’s filing date. The declaration was found to be insufficient to corroborate the testing and successful operation of the Randolph device.

In response to the order, Randolph and Dickinson both submitted supplemental declarations. In his supplemental declaration, Randolph stated that he had completely reduced his invention to practice prior to Shoberg’s filing date.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.