Court of Customs and Patent Appeals May 24, 1979, Appeal No. 79-514 (Godtfredsen v. Banner)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-05-1979
lead-opinion
BALDWIN, Judge.
Petitioner seeks writs of mandamus and prohibition directing the Commissioner of Patents and Trademarks to:
(1) substitute Count A (reciting a Markush group of compounds) as set forth in Petitioner’s “Motion to Amend By Substituting A New Count for the Present Count,” filed December 7, 1976, as the sole count in interference; and
(2) prohibit the interference from proceeding as currently constituted with counts 1, 2 and 3.
The Petition is dismissed.
Background
Interference 99,384 was declared on July 7, 1976, between Godtfredsen application Serial No. 554,423, filed March 3, 1975, and Bamberg et al. application Serial No. 464,-157, filed April 25, 1974. Both parties were accorded the benefits of earlier filed U.S. patent applications. Godtfredsen was designated the senior party by reason of his parent application filed April 13, 1972. The sole count in the interference declaration was directed to a method of treating bacterial infections by forming in the body a 1:1 mixture of a specific two-compound antibiotic mixture. During the motion period, Godtfredsen moved to substitute a broader count (Count A) directed to the same method, but covering the use of any of three related two-compound antibiotic mixtures, each mixture containing as. a common compound an amidopenicillanic acid (hereinafter mecillinam).
Godtfredsen also moved, contingent on the denial of the Motion to Substitute Count A, to add Count B and Count C. Counts B and C recited the two mixtures additionally found in Count A but not found in the original count.
The Primary Examiner denied the Motion to Substitute Count A noting that:
Count A is directed to three independent and distinct compositions comprising mecillinam and either (1) ampicillin (Count 1), (2) benzylpenicillin (proposed Count B) or (3) azidocillin (proposed Count C). Count A is, therefore, unpatentable since it is directed to a mixture of independent and distinct inventions under 35 U.S.C. § 121.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit