Court of Appeals of Georgia November 26, 1980, 59645 (Arthur Pew Construction Company, Inc. v. Bryan Construction Company, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-11-1980

Smith, Judge.

Appellant general contractor was named as defendant in a wrongful death action. Appellant (hereinafter “Pew”) then brought a third-party complaint against appellee subcontractor (hereinafter “Bryan”) asserting a contractual right of indemnity against Bryan for the claim filed against Pew. In the previous appearance of this case, this court held that the language of the subject indemnity clause was sufficient to require Bryan to indemnify Pew.

Arthur Pew Const. Co. v. Bryan Const. Co.,

148 Ga. App. 114 (251 SE2d 105) (1978). The issue raised by this appeal is whether the contract requires Bryan to completely indemnify Pew for a wrongful death claim arising from the parties’ concurrent negligence. The trial court granted Bryan’s motion for summary judgment, finding that if a “ [jury] finds that the concurrent negligence of both Bryan and Pew proximately caused injuries to Plaintiff, and if the [j]ury awards the Plaintiff damages for such injuries, the total damage award shall be assessed against Bryan and Pew on a comparative negligence basis; that is, based upon the percentage that the negligence of each caused or contributed to the damages.” We reverse.

The pertinent portions of the indemnification clause are as follows: “[Bryan] shall agree to hold [Pew], its officers, agents, and employees harmless from any and all claims made against [Pew], its officers, agents, and employees, which arise out of the action or

*781

omission of [Bryan]... and any and all claims which result from any condition created or maintained by [Bryan], which condition was not specified to be created or maintained by the contract.”

Argued April 15, 1980

Decided November 26, 1980

Rehearing denied December 10, 1980

Stevan A. Miller, W. Wray Eckl,

for appellant.

K. Morgan Varner, Thomas J. Wingfield, George Hart, Richard Goodman, William O. Green, Jr., Larry K. Butler,

for appellees.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.