Court of Appeals of North Carolina September 2, 1980, 8011DC168 (C & O DEVELOPMENT CO. v. American Arbitration Ass'n)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-09-1980

*551

WELLS, Judge.

The first issue we must resolve concerns the justiciability of the present action — whether the trial court had authority to enjoin arbitration on grounds of

res judicata

or collateral estoppel. Defendant argues that G.S. 1-567.3

1/

limits the basis upon which a court may stay arbitration proceedings solely to the issue of whether a written agreement to arbitrate a particular dispute exists and that all other matters, including factual and legal issues, are the proper subject matter of the arbitration itself. It is defendant’s position that the courts may determine

*552

any factual or legal issues involved only after the arbitration award has been entered. While we have found no cases in this State or other jurisdictions dispositive of this precise issue under the Uniform Act, it is our opinion that the extent of a judgment’s binding effect is a matter for judicial determination. Cf

., Rembrandt Ind. v. Hodges Int.,

38 N.Y. 2d 502, 381 N.Y.S. 2d 451, 344 N.E. 2d 383 (1976) (the scope of an arbitration award and its

res judicata

effect are issues properly determinable by the court and not the arbitrators);

accord, Weinberger v. Friedman,

41 A.D. 2d 620, 340 N.Y.S. 2d 720 (1st Dep’t 1973). We do not believe that in enacting the Uniform Act, the General Assembly intended to grant arbitrators the authority to determine the

res judicata

or collateral estoppel effect of a prior judgment. The arbitrability of various issues and disputes under the Uniform Act has, in general, been determined to be a matter for the courts to decide.

See, e.g., Ferris College v. Faculty Ass’n,

72 Mich. App. 244, 249 N.W. 2d 375 (1976),

cert. denied,

399 Mich. 861 (1977);

Layne-Minnesota Co. v. Regents of the University,

266 Minn. 284, 123 N.W. 2d 371 (1963).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.