Court of Appeals of North Carolina August 19, 1980, 8012SC65 (State v. Bell)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-08-1980

CLARK, Judge.

Defendant contends that the trial court committed reversible error by permitting the jury during deliberation to take three witnesses’ statements into the jury room in violation of N.C. Gen. Stat. § 15A-1233, which statute provides in relevant part:

“(b)

Upon request

by the jury and

with consent

of all parties, the judge

may in his discretion

permit the jury to take to the jury room exhibits and writings which have been received in evidence. If the judge permits the jury to take to the jury room requested exhibits and writings, he may have the jury take

additional material or first review other evidence relating to the same issue

so as not to give undue prominence to the exhibits or writings taken to the jury room. If the judge permits an exhibit to be taken to the jury room, he must, upon request, instruct the jury not to conduct any experiments with the exhibit.” [Emphasis added.]

We do not agree with defendant’s contention. There is no doubt that, pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat. § 15A-1233(b),

supra,

it was error for the trial court to submit the statements to the jury without the consent of defendant. The question before us, then, is whether such error is sufficiently prejudicial to warrant a new trial. “A defendant is prejudiced by errors relating to rights arising other than under the Constitution of the United States when there is a reasonable possibility that, had the error in question not been committed, a different result would

*363

have been reached at the trial out of which the appeal arises. The burden of showing such prejudice under this subsection is upon the defendant ... .” N.C. Gen. Stat. § 15A-1443(a).

Defendant, however, correctly cites

Gooding v. Pope,

194 N.C. 403, 140 S.E. 21 (1927);

Brown v. Buchanan,

194 N.C. 675, 140 S.E. 749 (1927);

Nicholsonv. Eureka Lumber Co.,

156 N.C. 59, 72 S.E. 86 (1911);

Williams v. Thomas,

78 N.C. 47

(1878); Burton v. Wilkes,

66 N.C. 604 (1872);

Watson v. Davis,

52 N.C. 178 (1859) and

Outlaw v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.