New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division January 16, 1980 (Nora v. Livingston Tp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-01-1980

171 N.J. Super. 579 (1980) 410 A.2d 278 FRANK NORA AND BONITA NORA, HIS WIFE, PLAINTIFFS, v. TOWNSHIP OF LIVINGSTON, DEFENDANT, AND PUBLIC SERVICE ELECTRIC AND GAS COMPANY, DEFENDANT-APPELLANT, AND SHERIDAN & SON, INC., DEFENDANT, AND COUNTY OF ESSEX, DEFENDANT-RESPONDENT. Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division. Submitted January 8, 1980. Decided January 16, 1980. *580 Before Judges FRITZ, KOLE and LANE. William S. Smith, attorney for appellant (Henry L. SanGiacomo, of counsel). Peter J. Stewart, attorney for respondent (Peter W. Rodino, III, on the brief). *581 PER CURIAM. Presented by this appeal is whether a joint tort-feasor whose negligence exceeds that of plaintiff is entitled to contribution from another joint tortfeasor whose negligence is less than plaintiff's. We conclude that there can be no contribution from a party not legally liable to the person injured. In his complaint plaintiff Frank Nora alleged that on August 13, 1975 he was injured when his motorcycle was upended when it hit a depression in the roadway. The jury returned a verdict of $6,000 against defendants Public Service and County of Essex, apportioning the negligence as follows: Public Service, 48%; plaintiff, 35%; and County of Essex, 17%. The trial judge molded the verdict so that Public Service would pay 48% and the County of Essex, 17% of the judgment. Subsequently plaintiffs moved "to determine the effect of the jury verdict against the respective defendants," complaining that the County of Essex had refused to pay its share on the ground that plaintiff's negligence exceeded that of the County of Essex. The trial judge ruled that Public Service should pay the entire judgment of $6,000, minus a deduction of 35% for plaintiff's contributory negligence. Public Service then moved for an order compelling the County of Essex to contribute its 17% share of the judgment, the full amount of which Public Service had already paid plaintiffs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.