Massachusetts Appeals Court December 8, 1980 (Commonwealth v. Durant)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-12-1980

Greaney, J.

The defendant was convicted by a jury on indictments charging armed robbery, rape, and entering a dwelling while armed with intent to commit a felony. He now contends (through counsel other than his trial counsel) that the judge erred by (1) giving incomplete and inadequate jury instructions on the question of identification;

*769

(2) denying the defendant’s motion for permission to sit at counsel table; and (3) failing to cure certain remarks made by the prosecutor in his summation. We find no error and affirm the convictions.

The Commonwealth introduced identifications of the defendant made by the victim and her next-door neighbor. The victim’s identifications were based on observations of her assailant made at two separate times on the day of the incident. The first encounter occurred about 11:30 a.m. and lasted approximately five minutes, when a man appeared at the victim’s door, inquired as to the whereabouts of her brother-in-law, and then left. The second encounter occurred at about 2:30 p.m., when the same man reappeared, entered the home and bound the victim. During the next thirty to forty minutes, he ransacked the house, threatened the victim at knifepoint, sexually assaulted her and instructed her not to “recognize” him.

1

After the incident, the victim provided the police with descriptions of the assailant and his automobile.

2

The next day she selected the defendant’s picture from a thirteen-photograph array. Subsequently, a second identification of the defendant was made by the victim when she picked him out from a group of eight to ten persons congregating in the rotunda area of the West Roxbury District Court.

3

The victim’s neighbor based her identification on her observations of a man acting suspiciously near an automobile parked by the victim’s home. She testified that she watched the man over an ap

*770

proximate forty-minute period, during which she had him in her field of vision on three separate five-minute occasions.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.