Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit April 23, 1980, 876, 79-2234 (Melvin Dubose v. Eugene Lefevre, Superintendent, Clinton Correctional Facility)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-04-1980
MANSFIELD, Circuit Judge:
This appeal from the denial of a petition for the writ of habeas corpus presents an episode of prosecutorial use of and failure to correct a witness’ false testimony in a criminal trial. We reverse.
Petitioner Melvin DuBose was convicted of second degree murder (N.Y.Penal Law § 125.25(2)) on June 5, 1975, after a jury trial in the New York Supreme Court, Bronx County, before Justice Donald Sullivan. The charges arose out of the 1970 death of DuBose’s 9-year old son Ronaldo, allegedly as the result of a beating by Du-Bose. The State’s ease relied almost entirely on the testimony of one Nancy Edwards, formerly DuBose’s girlfriend, an admitted prostitute, cocaine user, convicted of disorderly conduct, who had been held at Rikers Island on criminal charges for several months before she testified. She was the sole witness to the crime, and was under a felony indictment for hindering prosecution and helping dispose of the body. She gave extensive testimony implicating DuBose in the murder.
The State had little other persuasive evidence. Due to the lapse of time between the murder (as described by Edwards) and discovery of the skeleton in a box cemented in the basement of the building where Du-Bose and Edwards had lived, medical examiners could not identify the remains or determine the cause of death. Edwards’ 12-year old son testified that DuBose had sometimes abused Ronaldo and that around the time of the murder (five years earlier) there had been a smell “[l]ike meat rotting” in the apartment. A neighbor testified that in 1974, during the police investigation, Du-Bose had made an oblique comment to the effect that “all he did was beat him and put him to bed” and referred to “the thing-a-ma-jigs and the rocks and the basement.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit