Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit June 23, 1980, 79-1631 (In the Matter of Ben F. Garman, Bankrupt. The Northern Trust Company v. Ben F. Garman)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-06-1980
PELL, Circuit Judge.
Section 17(a)(2) of the Bankruptcy Act of 1938, 11 U.S.C. § 35(a)(2) (1960), provides that an individual’s debt shall not be discharged in bankruptcy if that debt or its renewal is the result of money obtained “in reliance [by the creditor] upon a materially false statement in writing respecting [the debtor’s] financial condition made or published ... with intent to deceive .... ” This appeal calls upon us to decide,
inter alia,
whether non-dischargeability is appropriate only where the creditor’s reliance under § 17(a)(2) is “reasonable.”
Ben F. Garman, the bankrupt, a life insurance salesman, had been a customer of the Northern Trust Bank (Northern) in Chicago since 1962. Between December, 1970, and March, 1973, Garman borrowed various sums from the Northern resulting in a total indebtedness on November 1, 1973, of $30,-000. On that date, Garman executed a renewal note to the Northern for the entire outstanding amount.
There is direct and unimpeached testimony in the record that the Northern, at least in part, expressly relied upon three financial statements submitted by Garman in making these loans.
1
It is uncontested by Garman that these statements omitted listing approximately $50,000 in “claims” that Garman later listed in his petition for bankruptcy.
2
These claims, however, are recorded as having arisen prior to the time Gar-man filed the statements with the Northern. Had these amounts been included as potential liabilities in the statements, they would have substantially reduced Garman’s net worth, in some instances to less than zero.
Upon Garman’s failure to pay the $30,000 when due in April of 1974, the Northern filed suit against him for this amount in state court. On February 6, 1975, prior to judgment in the state court, Garman filed a voluntary petition in bankruptcy listing as unsecured claims to be discharged the $30,-000 debt to the Northern as well as the $50,000 in claims not listed on his financial statements.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit