Court of Appeals of Texas March 20, 1980, No. 5390 (Mid-American Oil & Gas, Inc. v. Borchers)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-03-1980

DICKENSON, Justice.

The Borchers family 1 sued Mid-American Oil & Gas, Inc. for an alleged underpayment of royalties due on natural gas under the gas royalty clause of leases executed by the Borchers family, for an accounting, for exemplary damages, for attorney fees, and for prejudgment and postjudgment interest. Mid-American contended that the Borchers family was paid in full for all of their gas royalty interests under the terms of a Gas Purchase Contract.2 Following a lengthy trial, the jury returned its verdict in favor of Mid-American. The trial judge disregarded all but one of the jury’s findings and rendered judgment non obstante veredicto for the Borchers family against Mid-American Oil & Gas, Inc. for the sum of $4,445,526.00 as additional gas royalties due and $767,228.38 as prejudgment interest. Mid-American appeals. We reverse and render.

The verdict of the jury may be summarized as follows:

SPECIAL ISSUE NO. 1

The jury refused to find that Mid-American failed to pay royalties to the Borchers family based upon the amounts realized by Mid-American on gas produced from lands covered by the Borchers family’s leases and “sold at the wells,” from July 1, 1974, to December 31, 1977.

SPECIAL ISSUE NO. 2

A reasonable charge for compressing and transporting gas from the Borchers *805family’s leases to the pipeline delivery point is 1⅝<$. per MCF.

SPECIAL ISSUE NO. 3

This damage issue was conditionally submitted, and no answer was required in view of the “No” answer to issue 1.

SPECIAL ISSUE NO. 4

The jury refused to find that Mid-American failed to pay royalties to the Borchers family “based upon the market value at the well” of gas produced by Mid-American from the Borchers family’s leases from July 1,1974, to December 31, 1977.

SPECIAL ISSUE NO. 5

This damage issue was conditionally submitted, and no answer was required in view of the “No” answer to issue 4.

SPECIAL ISSUE NO.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.