Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York June 9, 1980 (People v. Garcia)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-06-1980
Appeal by defendant from a judgment of the Supreme Court, Queens County, rendered April 4, 1978, convicting him of manslaughter in the first degree and criminal possession of a weapon in the second degree, upon a jury verdict, and imposing sentence. Judgment reversed, on the law and as a matter of discretion in the interest of justice, and new trial ordered. Defendant’s conviction arose from actions he took during a pitched battle between rival labor unions at a Queens factory. During the course of the trial two errors occurred which require reversal of defendant’s conviction and a new trial. The indictment charged defendant with, inter alia, murder in the second degree, for causing the death of one Fernando Anon. Neither party requested a charge on the lesser included offense of manslaughter in the first degree at any time during the trial. *868After summation, the court informed the parties that it had decided, sua sponte, to charge the lesser included offense, and defense counsel excepted. The People candidly concede that the court’s failure to inform the parties prior to the summations of its intent to charge the lesser included offense violated CPL 300.10 (subd 3) and 300.30, but assert that such error was harmless under the circumstances, since the issue at bar involved the identification of defendant as the gunman. The defendant did not raise the issue of intent. While it has been held under similar circumstances that the defendant was not deprived of an effective summation (see People v Vicaretti, 54 AD2d 236), we believe that, in the instant case, "to deny, discount, or quantify the prejudice resulting from the trial court’s failure to adhere to the command of the Criminal Procedure Law is certainly a speculative indulgence. It requires first an hypothecation of what defense counsel would have stated if he had been informed of the charges to be submitted, and then a judgment of the impact on the jury of that theoretical summation.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit