New York Supreme Court January 30, 1980 (People v. Howard A. Weiss & Trap & Tripp, Ltd.)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-01-1980

OPINION OF THE COURT

Benjamin Altman, J.

The court faces the unusual question: Can the threatened loss of one’s business (livelihood) be sufficient to cause one to make involuntary statements to a private person?

The defendants have been charged with grand larceny in the second degree (Penal Law, § 155.35). The defendant now moves, pursuant to CPL 60.45 (subd 2, par [a]), to suppress certain statements as involuntarily made.

The factual situation is as follows.

Defendant ran a travel agency at 1775 Broadway, New York County, and, like most travel agencies, was a signatory to the Air Traffic Conference of America (ATC). On February 13, 1978, a senior enforcement officer of the ATC, Robert S. Price, with a colleague, Anthony Scozzafava, told defendant that he was going to make an inspection. Both men flashed their wallet identifications. Defendant asked what they wanted and gave them some material to commence their inspection, along with the use of a desk in his outer office to work on. The defendant had had a routine inspection by the ATC about a year and a half prior and assumed that this was a repeat of the routine inspection.

In about an hour both Price and Scozzafava came back and told defendant that he had substantial debits and showed defendant some vouchers and in sum told defendant he owed the ATC in excess of some $80,000.

There is conflicting testimony at this point. The People’s witness states that he spoke very quietly and never raised his voice.

*832The People contend the ATC enforcement officers found discrepancies in the defendant’s file. One of the officers said the defendant stated the amount of the discrepancy was $62,370, and proceeded to write out a check to Air Traffic Conference of America for that amount without the officers asking him to write the check.

The officer testified that the defendant did not. object to their return on the next day nor did they interfere with the attendance of the defendant at the funeral of a relative.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.