New York Surrogate's Court March 3, 1980 (In re the Estate of Kallman)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-03-1980

OPINION OF THE COURT

Millard L. Midonick, J.

In this vigorously and expertly litigated proceeding, the sole issue to be resolved concerns whether or not the decedent during his lifetime made an outright gift to the New York Public Library of the papers of Wystan Hugh Auden, the well-known poet. These papers consist of all manuscripts, letters, *340unpublished and published writings — all written materials belonging to him, found in his possession on his death. When assembled in Europe and finally delivered to the New York Public Library, which now claims as donee, those papers bulked to the point of filling a large suitcase.

There is no dispute as to how these papers of W. H. Auden first came to be owned by the decedent, Chester Kallman. The will of Auden, who died in Austria on September 29, 1973, bequeathed his entire estate to Kallman, between them there having been decades of open cohabitation. Kallman received from Auden’s estate not only the manuscripts and papers in controversy here, but also all of Auden’s copyrights, his real estate in Kirchstetten, a village near Vienna, Austria, together with all of Auden’s effects and tangible and intangible personal property.

The New York Public Library contends that it owns the Auden manuscripts and papers which it has possessed since October 11, 1974. The estate of the decedent, Chester Kallman, administered by the decedent’s father as sole distributee, has petitioned in this discovery proceeding for the return of all such papers in the possession of the New York Public Library, contending that no gift was ever consummated by the decedent Kallman to the library.

The Attorney-General of the State of New York, representing the public as ultimate charitable beneficiaries, takes the same position as the New York Public Library.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.