Indiana Court of Appeals September 29, 1980, No. 2-677A220 (F. J. v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-09-1980
MILLER, Judge.
This action consolidates appeals from a temporary civil commitment of respondent F. J., a 29 -year old physician, to Larue D. Carter Memorial Hospital and from the subsequent extension of such commitment. *374Both proceedings were brought pursuant to Ind.Code 16-14-9.1-1 et seq., an act pertaining generally to the care and treatment of mentally ill persons. With respect to her initial temporary commitment F.J. challenges the sufficiency of the evidence supporting her commitment and the constitutionality of the commitment statute. Additionally, she contends there were various procedural irregularities in her commitment hearing. Her further appeal-from the extension of such commitment-challenges only the constitutionality of the appropriate statute.
Although our decision determines the relevant statute is not constitutionally defective, and thus that the second commitment must stand, we further conclude the initial temporary commitment was in error. More specifically, we hold that the evidence presented at such hearing did not rise to a level even approaching “clear and convincing” proof, in part because the evidence in support of such commitment failed to reveal the testimony of at least one physician who had “personally examined” F.J. to determine her mental condition within the meaning of IC 16-14-9.1-7(e)(3). Accordingly, we affirm in part and reverse in part.
Our discussion of the facts relevant to the background of this case first observes that the appropriate statutory procedure concerning treatment of mentally ill persons prescribes three types of involuntary commitment or detention, all of which are pertinent to the procedures employed with respect to F.J. See IC 16-14-9.1-3. These three types are emergency detention, which may not exceed 72 hours; temporary commitment, which may be for 90 days and is renewable upon appropriate procedures for up to an additional 90 days and regular commitment, which may be for an indefinite period.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit