Ohio Supreme Court July 23, 1980, No. 79-1447 (General Motors Corp. v. McAvoy)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-07-1980

lead-opinion

Paul W. Brown, J.

The primary issue in the instant cause is whether the Director of Environmental Protection was under a statutory duty to provide an opportunity for an adjudication hearing prior to a denial of the permit sought by appellant. We hold that there is such a statutory duty imposed by R. C. Chapter 119.

It is undisputed that an order by the Director pf Environmental Protection denying permits to operate is an adjudication order within the meaning of R. C. 119.01(D).1 The validity of such orders is governed in part by R. C. 119.06, which provides that:

“No adjudication order shall be valid unless an opportunity for a hearing is afforded in accordance with sections 119.01 to *234119.13 of the Revised Code. Such opportunity for a hearing shall be given before making the adjudication order except in those situations where this section provides otherwise.” (Emphasis added.)

Therefore, an opportunity for a prior hearing is required unless one of the enumerated exemptions to the statute is applicable, or other statutory provisions render R. C. 119.06 inapplicable.

The preadjudication hearing requirement has three specific exceptions, only one of which is raised in this appeal. R. C. 119.06 provides:

“The following adjudication orders shall be effective without a hearing:

“(C) Orders or decisions of an authority within an agency if the rules of the agency or the statutes pertaining to such agency specifically give a right of appeal to a higher authority within such agency or to another agency and also give the appellant a right to a hearing on such appeal.” (Emphasis added.)

The Court of Appeals predicated its decision upon this exemption, holding that no prior hearing was necessary.

An analysis of this provision reveals a two-prong test before an adjudicative order is effective without a hearing. First, the order or decision must be from “an authority within an agency.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.