Louisiana Court of Appeal July 2, 1980, No. 7701 (Turner v. Broussard)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-07-1980

DOUCET, Judge.

Sheilah D. Turner brought this suit against her husband, Thomas James Brous-sard, seeking a separation from bed and board on the grounds of abandonment. Defendant answered, denying plaintiff’s allegation that he had abandoned her without lawful cause, and reconvened, seeking a judicial separation on the grounds of cruel treatment sufficient to render their living together insupportable. Following a trial, the district court rendered judgment in favor of plaintiff, granting her a separation from bed and board on the grounds of abandonment, and awarding her attorney's fees of $500, to be paid from the assets of the community of acquets and gains existing between them. Defendant’s reconventional demand was dismissed. Defendant appeals.

Article 143 of the Civil Code provides that the essential elements of abandonment are: (1) withdrawal from the common dwelling, (2) the absence of lawful cause for withdrawal, and (3) the withdrawing spouse’s constant refusal to return to live with the other.

Defendant argues on appeal that the trial judge erred in granting plaintiff a separation from bed and board on the grounds of abandonment, because she failed to prove the third element set above, i. e., his constant refusal to return to live with her. He further argues that the trial judge erred by failing to find that plaintiff’s cruel treatment of him was not only just cause for his leaving, but also adequate grounds for granting him the separation from bed and *197board that he sought by way of his recon-ventional demand.

Defendant relies on the decision of the court in Chamblee v. Chamblee, 340 So.2d 378 (La.App. 4th Cir. 1976) in support of his argument that plaintiff failed to prove the element of his constant refusal to return to live with her.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.