Montana Supreme Court May 12, 1980, 80-040 (State Ex Rel. Anderson v. DISTRICT CT., ETC.)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-05-1980

No. 80-40

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF MONTANA

1980

STATE OF MONTANA ex rel.,

HUGH V. ANDERSON,

Relators,

THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE

EIGHTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT OF

THE STATE OF MONTANA et al.,

Respondents.

ORIGINAL PROCEEDING:

Counsel of Record:

For Relator:

Jardine, Stephenson, Blewett and Weaver, Great Falls,

Montana

For Respondents:

J. Fred Bourdeau, County Attorney, Great Falls,

Montana

Submitted: April 24, 1980

~ecided

:

MAY I2 ?g@

- - .-

Mr. Chief Justice Frank I. Haswell delivered the Opinion of

the Court.

Relator Hugh V. Anderson was found in contempt of court

in the Cascade County District Court and fined $50.00. He now

applies for a writ of certiorari or supervisory control to re-

view the judgment of contempt.

Relator, a urological surgeon, while on "substitute duty"

in the emergency room of Columbus Hospital in Great Falls, Montana,

had treated one Robert L. Renville, who was at the time under

arrest. Thereafter, relator was served with a subpoena to attend

a trial regarding Renville. Subsequently, during a telephone con-

versation relator told a deputy county attorney that he had little

independent recollection of the incident, but would be willing to

testify to what recollection he had and the hospital records. The

deputy county attorney said he would contact relator later. Some-

time after that, relator received a message that the trial would

not be held as scheduled.

On or about December 4, 1979, a deputy sheriff delivered

a subpoena and a letter concerning Renville's January 14, 1980,

trial to relator's secretary. In an affidavit the deputy sheriff

stated that he believed the secretary to be more than 18 years

of age. On about December 5, the secretary showed the subpoena

and letter to the relator. The letter was from the deputy county

attorney stating that relator would be contacted regarding his

testimony ". . . at a time closer to the trial."

The deputy county attorney was not able to contact relator

despite three attempts.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.