Montana Supreme Court January 9, 1980, 14827 (Industrial Indemnity Co. v. McIntosh)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-01-1980

combined-opinion

No. 14827

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF MONTANA

1979

INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY COMPANY,

a corporation,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

DAVID McINTOSH,

Defendant and Appellant.

Appeal from: District Court of the Thirteenth Judicial District,

Honorable Robert H. Wilson, Judge presiding.

Counsel of Record:

For Appellant:

Olsen, Christensen & Gannett, Billings, Montana

Paul G. Olsen argued, Billings, Montana

For Respondent :

Anderson, Symmes, Brown, Gerbase, Cebull & Jones,

Billings, Montana

Steve Harman argued, Billings, Montana

Submitted: December 13, 1979

Decided :

ir'i

;if,,

5

- 1'

;4[u - 2 1933

Filed:

Clerk

Mr. Chief Justice Frank I. Haswell delivered the Opinion

of the Court.

Defendant David McIntosh appeals from a judgment

entered against him in Yellowstone County District Court.

The judgment grants plaintiff Industrial Indemnity Co.

indemnification from McIntosh for the amount paid in

settlement of a Workmen's Compensation claim. We affirm.

The case was submitted to the District Court on agreed

facts as follows: In a written contract dated April 30,

1974, McIntosh, an interstate hauler, agreed to provide a

truck and driver for Lewis Grover of Idaho Falls, Idaho.

Grover is an interstate carrier, certified by the Interstate

Commerce Commission (ICC). The contract contained two clauses

which are of particular importance to the resolution of the

case. They are:

" (11) . . . Contractor [McIntosh] shall save

carrier harmless from any liability arising

from the relationship between the contractor

and any of contractor's employees, agents and

servants, whether under industrial accident

laws, workmen's compensation laws, or any other

state or federal law applicable to employees

and employers. Contractor [McIntosh] shall

maintain workmen's compensation coverage for

all employees, agents or servants employed by

the contractor in the performance of this

contract . . .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.