Navajo Nation Court of Appeals April 10, 1980, No. A-CV-17-79 (Barton v. Charley)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-04-1980

ORDER

I. FACTS

This matter comes before the court on appeal from the Shiprock District Court. The cause of action arose from a shooting incident which occurred November 14, 1976, approximately one mile south of New Mexico State Road #504 near the traditional use areas of both families involved herein. Appellee's family maintains a winter residence approximately one-half mile from a corral constructed by Appellant's family. Previous to the day in question, a dispute had arisen between the families of Appellant and Appellee regarding the grazing of cattle and sheep in the area. An attempt to informally settle the dispute between the families was made before the District Grazing Committee on October 13, 1976, at which time it appeared that an agreement had been reached. However, on the day in question, an altercation ensued between Appellant and Appellee, the result of which was that Appellant shot Appellee.

Lewis Barton was charged subsequently in federal court and entered into a plea agreement in accordance with North Carolina v. Alford, 400 U.S. 25 (1970). He entered a plea to assault inflicting serious bodily injury upon the person assaulted, a misdemeanor violation of Arizona Revised Statute Section 13-245(A)(5) and deposited the sum of $2,000 in an irrevocable trust for the benefit of Herbert Charley's health, rehabilitation, education or vocational training. The period of the trust was five years and was to be administered under the supervision of the Navajo Tribal Court in Shiprock, New Mexico.

On February 2, 1978, Herbert Charley filed a civil complaint in the Shiprock District Court seeking damages in the amount of $250,000.00 for the injuries inflicted upon him as a result of the shooting.

*6The Shiprock District Court, by judgment dated July 7, 1979, specifically held:

1. That Appellant attempted to prevent the Appellee from grazing his livestock on land claimed by the Appellant,

2.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.