District Court of Appeal of Florida November 25, 1981, 81-946 (Kristensen v. Kristensen)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-11-1981

406 So.2d 1210 (1981) Hilmar KRISTENSEN, Petitioner, v. Baerbel KRISTENSEN, Respondent. No. 81-946. District Court of Appeal of Florida, Fifth District. November 25, 1981. Rehearing Denied December 18, 1981. *1211 Henry J. Martocci, Cocoa, for petitioner. W. Ford Duane of Robertson, Williams, Duane, Lewis & Ranson, P.A., Orlando, for respondent. SHARP, Judge. The petitioner, Hilmar Kristensen, seeks review by certiorari of the trial court's requirement that both Hilmar and his wife, Baerbel, submit to compulsory mental and physical examinations pursuant to Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.360. We grant the writ and quash the lower court's order because the mental and/or physical health of the parties to this dissolution action was not in controversy, and good cause for the examinations was not shown. We reject respondent's argument that the mental health of any parent seeking custody of his or her child is in controversy simply because there are allegations that one or the other would be the better parent to have custody. In this case there was no allegation that either Hilmar or Baerbel was unfit to have custody, or that either had any kind of mental or physical illness or condition which would adversely affect his or her ability to be the custodial parent. Under these circumstances, although the "mental and physical health of the parents" is a factor the court should consider in resolving the issue of custody,[1] it is not in controversy until raised by one of the parties in his or her pleadings, or by a proper motion.[2] Further, Rule 1.360 requires a showing of "good cause" why the forced examination is necessary. No such showing was made here by the respondent. Her motion for the examination of her husband merely asserts in a conclusory way that Hilmar's mental condition is in issue. The trial judge sua sponte ordered the examination of the wife without any request by the husband.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.