Louisiana Court of Appeal November 2, 1981, 14694 (Ramphrey v. Highlands Ins. Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-11-1981

406 So.2d 691 (1981) Jessie D. RAMPHREY and Adelaide Ramphrey, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. HIGHLANDS INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant-Appellee. No. 14694. Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit. November 2, 1981. *692 Blackwell, Chambliss, Hobbs & Henry by James A. Hobbs, West Monroe, for plaintiffs-appellants. Davenport, Files, Kelly & Marsh by William G. Kelly, Jr., Monroe, for defendant-appellee. Before HALL, MARVIN and FRED W. JONES, Jr., JJ. HALL, Judge. The sole issue on appeal in this case is quantum. Plaintiffs-appellants argue that the $31,000 general damage award made by the trial court is inadequate and should be increased to $50,000. Defendant-appellee, who answered the appeal, argues that the award is excessive and should be reduced to $20,000. The parties agree that the $3,640.15 award for special damages was an inadvertent error and should be increased to $8,421.13. We amend the judgment to correct this error and otherwise affirm. Mrs. Ramphrey was injured on August 12, 1979 when the pickup truck in which she was a passenger was struck from the rear by another vehicle. She was taken to the hospital emergency room where a doctor diagnosed her injuries as an anterior subluxation (partial dislocation) of the fourth cervical vertebra upon the fifth, with a possible fracture of the fourth cervical vertebra. Her neck was immobilized and she was transferred to another hospital for neurological evaluation. The neurosurgeon concurred in the original diagnosis and advised fusion surgery. The alternative to surgery was conservative treatment with traction, casts, and braces. Mrs. Ramphrey refused to undergo surgery at first because of her anxiety concerning the possibility of damage to her spinal cord. Tongs were attached to her skull so that traction could be applied; Mrs. Ramphrey was completely immobilized for several days. She later consented to the surgery which was performed on August 21.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.