Court of Appeals of Arizona June 3, 1981, 2 CA-CIV 3573 (Hellyer v. Hellyer)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-06-1981

OPINION

BIRDSALL, Judge.

This case comes to our court for the second time. In

Hellyer v. Hellyer,

119 Ariz. 365, 580 P.2d 1219 (App.1978) we reversed a partial summary judgment entered by the trial court. We held there that the doctrine of judicial estoppel did not preclude the appellant here, John Tirrell Hellyer, from contending that the gift which is the principal subject matter of this appeal was subject to a condition subsequent. This appeal arises following a judgment of the trial court in the dissolution action between the parties in which the court held that the appellant had made an unconditional gift of all his substantial estate to the appellee.

The parties were married on January 11, 1975. On January 13 appellant executed a deed to his residence and other documents of title to personal property giving these properties to his new wife. The gift had been previously discussed in the office of his attorney on January 3. The property which was the subject matter of the gifts constituted all of the appellant’s estate except that he remained as the beneficiary of a trust from which he received an annual income of approximately $19,000. The value of the gift properties was approximately $163,679. The appellant claimed and testified in the trial court that there was an oral agreement between the parties which provided that in the event the marriage failed, all of the gift properties would be returned to him. The appellee denied any such oral agreement.

The judgment of the trial court found the gift properties to be the sole and separate property of the appellee, granted a dissolution of the marriage and ordered no spousal maintenance.

The appellant was previously married to Joan Hellyer and that marriage ended in divorce in 1969. Joan Hellyer, in an action in the Pima County Superior Court, sought to have the gift declared fraudulent as to her because of her status as a creditor entitled to support from the appellant.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.