California Supreme Court August 6, 1981, L.A. 31334 (Wells v. Marina City Properties, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-08-1981

combined-opinion

29 Cal.3d 781 (1981) 632 P.2d 217 175 Cal. Rptr. 104 W.G. WELLS, Plaintiff and Respondent, v. MARINA CITY PROPERTIES, INC., et al., Defendants and Appellants. Docket No. L.A. 31334. Supreme Court of California. August 6, 1981. *783 COUNSEL Latham & Watkins, A. Victor Antola and Stephen L. Jones for Defendants and Appellants. Gerald M. Siegel for Plaintiff and Respondent. OPINION RICHARDSON, J. We examine and resolve an apparent conflict between two subdivisions of Code of Civil Procedure section 581. (All further statutory references are to that code unless otherwise cited.) Subdivision 1 gives a plaintiff a right to dismiss his action without prejudice "at any time before the actual commencement of trial." Subdivision 3, on the other hand, affords a defendant a right to obtain dismissal of such action with prejudice after the trial court has sustained, with leave to amend, defendant's general demurrer, and plaintiff has failed to so amend. We will conclude that in such a conflict, a defendant's right to a dismissal with prejudice prevails. On August 4, 1978, defendants' general demurrer to plaintiff's second amended complaint was sustained with leave to amend within 30 days. The time for such amendment subsequently was extended to September 26. Plaintiff sought no further extensions and did not amend his complaint. On October 5, defendants filed and served upon plaintiff by mail a notice of a motion to be heard October 20 for a dismissal with prejudice of plaintiff's action, pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section 581, subdivision 3. *784 On October 6, plaintiff filed a request for dismissal of his action without prejudice, pursuant to section 581, subdivision 1. The clerk of the court entered a dismissal without prejudice in accordance with the statute; and plaintiff gave to defendants written notice thereof.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.