Supreme Court of Colorado August 31, 1981, 80SA403 (People v. Christian)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-08-1981

QUINN, Justice.

Darryl Christian (defendant) was convicted of the crimes of child abuse, section 18-6 — 401, C.R.S.1973 (1978 Repl. Vol. 8), a class three felony, and reckless manslaughter, section 18-3-104(l)(a), C.R.S.1973 (1978 Repl. Vol. 8), a class four felony. In this appeal he contends that the disparity in the statutory penalties for the two offenses violates equal protection of the laws, that the court erred in its rulings on numerous evidential matters during the trial, and that the evidence presented at trial was insufficient to support his conviction for child abuse.

1

We affirm.

I.

Trial Proceedings

The indictment charged the defendant in one count with felony child abuse on April 27, 1979, and in another count with reckless manslaughter on the same date. The defendant, an enlisted man in the army, was stationed at Fort Carson and lived off-base in Colorado Springs with his wife, Lynette, and their three and one-half month old daughter, Eileen. The charges arose out of the death of the daughter and the cause of her death was the primary issue contested during trial. The prosecution’s case was complicated by the recalcitrance of the defendant’s wife to testify in accordance with her prior statements to the police and her grand jury testimony regarding the defendant’s conduct toward the child.

During the late afternoon of April 27, 1979, the defendant had exclusive custody of the child while his wife went shopping. The child recently had been treated for a cold and a loss of appetite but, except for some intermittent crying, appeared to be in reasonably good condition when the wife left the apartment. Upon the wife’s return from the shopping trip about 90 minutes later, the defendant was outside their apartment in an agitated state and told her that the child was “stiff.” Although he had no explanation for the child’s condition, it was apparent to both parents that the child’s limbs had begun to rigidify.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.