Court of Appeals of Oregon March 23, 1981, 19-880, CA 17467 (State v. Divers)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-03-1981
*353
CAMPBELL, J.
PRO TEMPORE.
Defendant entered pleas of guilty to the offenses of assault in the fourth degree (ORS 163.160) and theft in the second degree (ORS 164.045), both Class A misdemeanors. The incident occurred in a retail store. A security officer, Thomas Moore, observed defendant remove his boots and put them on a shelf and take new boots from the shelf and put them on his feet. The officer started to say something to defendant about the boots when defendant struck him, breaking his nose. Moore was unable to work for a number of days. His employer paid him lost time benefits during his time off. The employer was in turn reimbursed by its workers’ compensation insurer.
Defendant alleges the trial court erred: (1) by ordering him to make restitution to the insurer in the amount of $662 for payment of the lost time benefits;
1
(2) by failing to state on the record adequate reasons to justify the imposition of consecutive jail terms; and (3) by imposing consecutive jail sentences which defendant claims are excessive and constitute cruel and unusual punishment. We affirm except as to the order of restitution.
*354
In
State v. Stalheim,
275 Or 683, 552 P2d 829 (1976), the court narrowly construed Oregon’s restitution statute and held that a convicted offender could only be ordered to make restitution to the "direct victim” of the crime. Subsequently, in
State v. Getsinger,
27 Or App 339, 556 P2d 147 (1976), we found that the insurer of a vehicle was not the direct victim of defendant’s unauthorized use of the vehicle. We held the defendant was improperly ordered to make restitution to the insurer even though the insurer suffered a loss by paying a claim arising out of the unauthorized use.
See also State v. Rose,
45 Or App 879, 609 P2d 875 (1980).
In 1977, the legislature responded to the Supreme Court’s opinion in
State v. Stalheim, supra,
by substantially amending the restitution statutes. Or Laws 1977, ch 371.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit