Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals March 31, 1981, NO. 7571 (State v. Lima)
Also known as
United States · · · 31-03-1981
Per-Curiam.
Appellant William Lima, III appeals his conviction for rape in the first degree,
Hawaii Revised Statutes
(HRS) § 707-730. He contends there was not substantial evidence to support the jury’s conclusion of guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. We agree and reverse.
The government’s evidence at trial established the following: On April 1, 1979, at approximately 4:00 p.m., 14-year-old Stacey South asked appellant, the husband or ex-husband of Stacey’s first cousin, for a ride home from a friend’s house. Appellant and his wife or ex-wife lived next door to Stacey. Appellant agreed to the ride and after driving for a short time asked Stacey if she would like to “steal” some marijuana plants with him. She agreed and the two proceeded to the park at the top of St. Louis Heights.
Once at the park, appellant told Stacey to bring her towel to hide the marijuana plants. He led her down a trail to a flat, grassy opening
*20
in the trees approximately 300 yards from a parking lot. Appellant told Stacey to sit down; once seated, the two shared some chewing gum while appellant questioned her about the design on her blouse. After touching the design, he pinned Stacey’s shoulder to the ground with his left hand and moved his right hand inside of her blouse to her breast. When she told him to remove his hand, he told her to “shut up” and began to unbutton her shorts. She protested, “Willy, why are you doing this to me, you’re my cousin,” and began to cry. After removing her shorts and panties, appellant released Stacey and took off his own trousers. Stacey cried, “Don’t do it; I have my period”, but appellant removed her tampax and completed the carnal act.
According to her testimony at trial, Stacey was “scared to death” during the incident.
After appellant removed himself from Stacey, she wiped herself with the towel she had brought and followed appellant back to the car.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit