Utah Supreme Court July 31, 1981, 16898 (State v. Stettina)
Also known as
United States · · · 31-07-1981
STEWART, Justice:
Defendant was charged and convicted of rape, a felony of the second degree, in violation of § 76-5 — 402, Utah Code Ann. (1953), as amended. On appeal from the conviction, defendant contends that the evidence as a matter of law was insufficient to support a conviction for rape.
There is no disagreement that shortly before the incident the prosecutrix and the defendant met in a tavern and stepped outside together. They decided to smoke marijuana and proceeded across the street to a sloped, grassy area where they would be out of view. It is not disputed that sexual intercourse between the two occurred. To support his contention that there was consent, defendant points out that there was no evidence of screams or physical resistance, and in particular, no evidence of bruises, lacerations, or other physical injury. Furthermore, defendant claims that the prosecutrix’s verbal refusals were accompanied with laughter and that the prosecutrix permitted him to kiss her afterwards and to hold her hand while returning to the tavern. She also agreed to talk with him later.
The prosecutrix testified that she behaved in this manner because defendant threatened to kill her (which he denies) and consequently was scared, anxious not to show that she was scared, and afraid that if she was not agreeable she would suffer greater injury and would not be returned safely to the tavern.
Defendant contends that the testimony of the prosecutrix was so inherently improbable that it was unworthy of belief and that evidence of corroboration was required. In particular, defendant asserts that the prose-cutrix’s claim of lack of consent is supported only by her own assertion to that effect.
The evidence should be evaluated in a manner consistent with the verdict,
State v. Jones,
Utah, 554 P.2d 1321 (1976);
*77
State v. Howard,
Utah, 544 P.2d 466 (1975). Nevertheless, the evidence in a rape case must be carefully scrutinized to avoid unmerited conviction,
Tibbs v. State,
Fla.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit