Utah Supreme Court August 31, 1981, 17113 (Schmidt v. Intermountain Health Care, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-08-1981

DEE, District Judge:

Plaintiff sued defendant alleging negligence on the part of a nurse employed by defendant in performing a catheterization. Plaintiff appeals following a jury verdict for defendant. We affirm.

Plaintiff was admitted to a hospital owned and operated by defendant. Subsequent to her hysterectomy, it was necessary for her to be catheterized on a number of occasions to allow evacuation of the bladder. In the catheterization procedure, a tube is inserted through the urethra into the bladder allowing the urine in the bladder to be drained through a rubber tube into a plastic bag. The tube can be taped to the body, allowing the patient to walk about with the apparatus in place. The catheterization which gave rise to this lawsuit was the twelfth performed on plaintiff during that hospital visit. Plaintiff testified as follows: Upon the performance of the catheterization in question, she experienced unusual pain. She rang for a nurse, complained of the pain, and was advised to go for a walk. She took a walk down the hall to the room of another patient. While there, she experienced considerable pain and lightheadedness and needed help returning to her own room. The other patient testified that the bag attached to plaintiff to catch the urine from the evacuation of the bladder had filled with fresh blood. However, plaintiff’s chart indicated neither a blood-filled bag, nor unusual pain as testified to by the plaintiff. Plaintiff brought this suit seeking recovery for her recurrent urinary difficulties, which she alleges were caused by the negligent cath-eterization performed by defendant’s nurse. These difficulties include inability to void and susceptibility to infection, which have necessitated frequent medical attention and caused her continual distress and difficulty in holding employment. After hearing evidence by both sides, the jury returned a verdict for defendant, finding negligence on the part of defendant but no proximate cause.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.