Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals June 5, 1981, NO. 7152 (Phillips v. Kula 200, Wick Realty, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-06-1981

*207

OPINION OF THE COURT BY

BURNS, J.

Defendants interlocutorily appeal the lower court’s Order Denying Motion to Dismiss Derivative Action and for Summary Judgment.

The issue is whether the lower court correctly ruled that two limited partners may maintain a derivative action in favor of the limited partnership against the limited partnership, the two general partners, and one limited partner. We affirm.

Defendant-Appellant KULA 200 is a Hawaii limited partnership.

1

Defendant-Appellant Wick Realty, Inc., is a Hawaii corporation and it and Defendant-Appellant Erling P. Wick are the two general partners of KULA 200. Defendant-Appellant Wick Associates is a Hawaii partnership and one of the limited partners of KULA 200. Defendant-Appellant Erling P. Wick is one of four partners in Wick Associates, and he is president and owner of 25 percent of the stock of Wick Realty, Inc. Plaintiffs-Appellees Donald L. Phillip and Neil O. Warner are limited partners of KULA 200, and they together own a one thirty-sixth (1/36) or 2.78 percent limited partnership interest therein.

According to its Certificate of Limited Partnership (CLP), KULA 200 was “formed to purchase, hold, sell, lease, subdivide and/or improve those certain parcels of land” which it was acquiring from Wick Associates in return for an allocation of six limited partnership units and an assumption of a $228,750 mortgage.

On May 22,1978, plaintiffs “individually and as limited partners of KULA 200, a Hawaii limited partnership, on behalf of themselves and all other limited partners similarly situated and in the right and for the benefit of said limited partnership,”

2

filed a verified com

*208

plaint, alleging that Wick Realty and Erling Wick intentionally, wilfully, and fraudulently breached the fiduciary duties they owed to the limited partners, thus causing damage to the limited partners. Specifically, they alleged:

1.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.