New Mexico Supreme Court November 3, 1981, 13515 (Amoco Production Co. v. Sims)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-11-1981

OPINION

RIORDAN, Justice.

This case involves an appeal from a permanent injunction issued by the Lea County District Court which restrained appellant (Sims) from denying appellee (Amoco) the use of a private road across Sims’ property. We reverse and remand.

On August 11, 1952, Edgar Watkins conveyed the surface rights to 640 acres of land in Lea County, New Mexico, to members of the Sims family. The warranty deed reserved to Watkins the oil and gas mineral rights underlying 320 acres of the property along with “the right to ingress and egress for the purpose of developing same.” The deed was signed only by Watkins and contained no words of grant or conveyance by Sims. At the time of the Watkins conveyance, Sims owned the surface rights to approximately ten sections of land in the area, portions of which abutted the north and east boundaries of the Watkins tract. The remaining Watkins property was bordered by land belonging to the State of New Mexico. There is no record before us of any grants of easements or of access routes across any of the Sims or State lands into the Watkins property at the time of the conveyance. Subsequently, Sims purchased additional land from the State, and the 640-acre tract became surrounded by property owned by Sims.

A road was constructed across the Sims land in the years following the Watkins transaction by various oil and gas operators. Part of the road is on land owned by Sims at the time of the Watkins transaction, and part of it is on land subsequently acquired by Sims. Sims was paid rentals and damages for the creation and use of the road by previous operators. After the road was built, Amoco obtained an oil and gas lease from Watkins. When Amoco attempted to use the established road to reach the estate, they were prevented from doing so by Sims.

Amoco brought suit in the District Court of Lea County seeking to have Sims enjoined from denying them access to the leased property.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.