District Court, N.D. Florida April 22, 1981, TCA 76-163, 76-172 and 78-0938 (Norton v. Tallahassee Memorial Hospital)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-04-1981

ORDER OF DISQUALIFICATION OF COUNSEL

HIGBY, District Judge.

At the risk of posing a rhetorical question, can an attorney/City Commissioner

*778

continue to represent a class of plaintiffs in a racial discrimination case against a defendant hospital which, under certain circumstances, could be directly controlled by the City Commission and is presently represented by the firm of the City Attorney?

These consolidated Title VII actions were scheduled for hearing on motion for class certification on March 2 and 3, 1981. On February 24, 1981, plaintiffs’ lead counsel, Kent Spriggs, had the fortune, or the misfortune, as the case may be, to be elected as a City Commissioner of the City of Tallahassee. He took the oath of that office on February 27, 1981. On February 26, 1981, in light of this development, a brief hearing was held, at which time the court expressed its concern over whether lawyer/City Commissioner Spriggs could continue in his present capacity and role as plaintiffs’ lead counsel. The class certification hearing was continued, and the matter of the potential conflict of interest generated by Mr. Spriggs’ election was heard on March 3, 1981.

A formal motion seeking Mr. Spriggs’ disqualification is now before the court, and the parties have been granted ample opportunity to brief this delicate ethical subject. The defendant’s counsel maintains that an

actual conflict of interest inheres in City Commissioner/attorney Spriggs’ continued representation of the named plaintiffs as lead counsel and that the problem is compounded by the dictates of Rule 23(d), Fed. R.Civ.P., concerning the adequacy of counsel. The plaintiffs’ counsel say not only is there no actual conflict of interest, but there’s not even an apparent conflict of interest. Both positions are too extreme, as will be more fully discussed.

The following facts appear of record without dispute. Since September 22,1976, Kent Spriggs has represented Norton and the purported class as lead counsel.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.